Meet the penpoint gunnel — an eel-shaped Pacific shore fish that changes colour with its seaweed and guards eggs in a ball under the rocks.
Turn over a rock on a low Pacific tide, anywhere from Kodiak Island to southern California, and there is a fair chance something long, green and astonishingly slippery will try to leave. Confusion is the standard reaction. It looks like an eel. It moves like an eel. It is not an eel. It is a penpoint gunnel (Apodichthys flavidus), and few animals on the American west coast spend so much of their lives being misidentified — by beachcombers, by research students on their first tide-pooling weekend, and by the occasional reference text that still places it with the true eels.
The penpoint gunnel is the largest member of the gunnel family, the Pholidae, in Pacific waters. It grows to thirty centimetres or more — some references considerably more — spends its life among the fronds and crevices of the kelp beds and rocky intertidal, changes its colour to match the seaweed it is sitting in, and when threatened will flick itself out of a tidepool and assemble its body into what appears, for half a moment, to be a small, indignant green snake. It is, in other words, an excellent fish, and learning it properly is one of the better investments a Pacific coast naturalist can make.
The penpoint is long, compressed and ribbon-like, built less like a fish and more like a eel-shaped leaf. The dorsal fin runs the entire body's length on soft rays — this, alone, distinguishes it visually from its nearest relatives, whose dorsals bristle with sharp spines. The dorsal is low, the anal fin is long, the pectorals are small and delicate, and the tail is a neat little paddle on the end of a long whip of a body. Scales are tiny and buried in the skin, which gives the whole animal a polished, almost glazed look, as if the fish has been lacquered.
The head is the giveaway and the origin of the name. Behind and through the eye runs a series of dark, pen-and-ink streaks — hatch marks that look, to the 19th-century naturalists who named the fish, like the nibs of a quill pen. The markings are distinctive across the family. The colour of the body varies hugely. In mid-shore green weed the fish is bright emerald green, sharp and difficult to believe. On red algae it drops through rust and brick red. On kelp it runs olive to chocolate. It genuinely looks like three different fish depending on the week.
Green forms were long thought to take their colour from the green algae around them, and the red forms from red algae, along the lines of the better-documented diet-driven colour system seen in some other reef camouflage experts like the giant kelpfish. The current understanding is that colour does track the background vegetation — and that greens and reds are at least partly separate, background-matched forms with pigment production matching what they grew up on. The greens occur mostly where green weed dominates; the reds where the turf goes red; the olives where brown kelp dominates. The mechanism remains less perfectly worked out than the pattern, which is tidy, scientific and satisfyingly visible.
The penpoint is a creature of exactly the edge most people muddy themselves on. It lives from the mid intertidal among the rockweed and the boulders down to the shallowest subtidal kelp beds, often to several metres below low water. In the intertidal it is a famous rock-flipping animal, sheltering in the slime and moisture under stones at low tide. Essentially all of its life is spent within a few metres of the shore, among kelp, eelgrass and green algal turfs, always close to structure and cover.
Geographically it covers the Pacific coast from the Kodiak archipelago in the north through British Columbia and Washington — easy in Puget Sound's protected rockweed edges — to central California, where it thins out and hands the shallowist gunnel niche over to rarer, warmer relatives.
The gunnels are the Pholidae, and they are one of the most poorly appreciated families of north temperate fishes. They are all long-bodied, viviparous-looking and intertidal, with the fine lateral line that gives the family its Greek name — pholis, meaning scale. Their nearest relatives in fish guides are the pricklebacks, the eelpouts and the wolf eels — all elongate, bottom-adapted north Pacific families occupying slightly different rungs and habitats. There is no close relation to the true eels, which are a completely different branch of fish evolution; the similarity is pure convergence, arrived at because an eel-shaped fish can fit where nothing rounder can.
Among gunnels, the penpoint is distinctive as one of the largest and most kelp-focused. Its closest companion in a rock flip is often the crescent gunnel, a smaller, more spotted and more strictly intertidal species, and the monkeyface prickleback, a longer California specialist that becomes, at adulthood, the true eel-sized animal of the larger rocks. Comparisons are useful but the penpoint soft dorsal, pen-streaked head and magic colour-matching are enough on their own.
The intertidal is not a gently unpredictable home. Twice a day the water goes; the oxygen goes with it; the temperature rises and falls; the gulls come. The penpoint gunnel endures all of it through a combination of adaptability that looks less like fish behaviour and more like an amphibious animal's. It hangs on in pockets of water and damp weed. It will live under a lifted boulder through a complete low tide if the weather is mild. Like several gunnels and pricklebacks, it is able to pick up oxygen across its body surfaces and maintain itself in conditions that would kill a lot of fish with more ordinary systems. It is fully a fish — it never leaves the damp habitat — but it is a fish engineered to the outer edge of the fish life, tuned for the intertidal's daily routine of crisis.
The same adaptation makes it outstanding at surviving the low oxygen and heat of tidepool ponds. Anyone studying the population-level resilience of kelp and algal shore fish in a warming climate finds the penpoint a useful anchor: it is already tolerating extremes that other fish never see, which makes its response to the next tier of change instructive.
Reproduction is intertidal, fixed and practical. In the winter, females lay a compact, nearly spherical mass of adhesive eggs — several hundred at a sitting — clamped into a rock den or underside crevice in the lower intertidal. The mass looks oddly like a small ball of sticky pearls; this structure serves a hydrodynamic purpose on a shore of breaking wave, but it also makes the eggs defensible in a way that scattered spawn could never be. And defended they are, thoroughly, by both sexes: one or both parents coil around the egg ball, moving it, fanning it, and staying put for the weeks it takes the embryos to develop. On the roughest shore, the little ball survives a winter of weather no tide year-round could be laid out to.
Larvae go to sea with the spring plankton and eventually settle back inshore with the kelp and weed. The cycle is exceptionally well suited to a shore where anything left exposed doesn't make it.
Penpoint gunnels are both herbivore-adjacent and ambush predator. Their diet is mainly small crustaceans — the amphipods and isopods of the kelp understory, along with polychaetes and anything else they can take from the fronds. But they are also among a small number of shore fish that browse directly on the seaweeds they shelter in, and this mixed feeding role is one of the reasons the fish makes an appearance in the theoretical treatment of the kelp forest's small-fish ecology. Among the fish-sized grazers and browsers of the Pacific kelp understory, the penpoint sits at the overlap between the pure seaweed-eaters (like the greenbone butterfish or the herring cale) and the pure carnivores of the algal edge.
In practice the fish's ecological function is the same as the other gunnels and pricklebacks: it is a dedicated convertor of the massive crustacean productivity of the algal understory into fish biomass, and a ready food for the larger predators of the shore. River otters, glaucous gulls and other shore-feeding seabirds, and bigger fish all take them. Their presence is a normal sign of a functioning kelp bed understory; away from healthy shore weed, the penpoint simply isn't there.
The penpoint gunnel is not protected, listed or threatened. It is broadly distributed, abundant in the right habitat, and not the object of any fishery. Its habitats are nonetheless among the most pressured in the coastal system's inventory: the intertidal fringe receives every footfall, every tidepool net, every causeway and every shading development. The species itself is not in trouble — but the messy, productive boulder-bound margin of the kelp coast it depends on is shrinking in places, unevenly, and climate change is compiling both the intertidal heat spikes that test its air-weathering adaptations and the weed-bed degradation that strips its home.
For naturalists it is one of the most educational fish available. A careful coastal surveyor, a first-year tide pooler or a child patient enough to lift and lower one boulder can get a proper look at a body plan and a colour system as subtle as anything found in the tropics. That is exactly as it should be for the eel-that-isn't living at everybody's feet.
No. It is a member of the gunnel family (Pholidae), which is part of the sculpin line of fishes. True eels are a different order altogether. The similarity is convergent evolution — eel-shaped bodies let fish fit into the narrow spaces between weed and rock that nobody else can.
The crescent gunnel is smaller, with a dorsal fin that visibly carries spiny rays, a spotted or banded body pattern, and a distinctive pale crescent mark behind the pectoral fin. The penpoint is larger, soft-dorsaled, and usually matches its weed background much more closely. In-hand, the soft dorsal is decisive.
The fish's body colour matches the dominant algae in its home habitat. The greens live in green algae; the reds live among the red algal turfs; the olives among brown kelp. The exact mechanism is not fully resolved, but it is a background-matching system with at least partial diet or environmental influence, and it is visible and intuitive to follow at the shore.
Any mid- to low-intertidal boulder shore on the Pacific coast from central California north is potential penpoint habitat. They're especially reliable in sheltered intertidal weed in Puget Sound, the San Juan Islands and the northern kelp coasts. Lift a boulder carefully on a mild, low tide and you may find one with minimal effort.
It is sometimes kept and does well in a dedicated cool, weed-filled marine tank, surviving far better than most intertidal fish. However, like any coolwater shore fish it needs a highly specific temperature and structure, and removal from intertidal habitats shouldn't be routine. It does far better observed where it is.
Meet the saddleback gunnel — the saddle-marked, eel-shaped shore fish of Pacific kelp edges, and how to tell it from true eels and its gunnel relatives.
Dr. Mara Ellison ·
Meet the crescent gunnel — the crescent-marked, rock-flipping eel-lookalike of Pacific tidepools, and why its colours make it a barometer of the weed it lives in.
Dr. Theo Nakamura ·
The masked greenling is a small, dark-barred reef fish of Alaska's shallow kelp and eelgrass beds. How to identify it — and the nest-guarding life it leads.
Dr. Theo Nakamura ·